Wednesday, August 20, 2008

Hasbro, With the Dumbed-Down and Tarted-Up Video Game, In the Toy Aisle

Let's get one thing straight: my family is a Clue family. Though I am two thousand miles from my mother's house, I would lay down a sizable wager that somewhere in the living room/dining room area, a Clue board is stashed beneath a couch or in the cabinet beneath the china hutch.



We are so “Clue” that we can recite the movie for you line by line.


Let's get another thing straight: You Can't Beat Me At Clue. There is one person on this planet who can beat me at clue, and you ain't him. My brother Jim started giving me a run for my money right about the time the logic primers started piling up on his desk during his junior year at the university. He has his strategy, I have mine. God help you if you are an unlucky soul trapped in a game with the two of us. You might as well eat your cards. You stand no chance.



We could also be accused of being a Skip-Bo family, and this I would not argue. It is such an underrated game.



Ok, Ok, I'm getting off topic here.

Our family is a Clue family, and we've had all of the editions of the game over the years. We had some video game version of it on a long obsolete console. I got the “expanded version” for Christmas in junior high. Remember that one? With extra characters like Ms. Peach, Lady Lavender and Prince Azure and fancy schmancy rooms like the fountain and the carriage house?

Even in the last couple of years we got Clue DVD. My brother, sister and best friend spent an embarrassing number of hours tearing through that thing. (Hey, Lisa? Can you take some time off of law school and come devour clue with us late into the night? Great, thanks, bring beer.)Clue DVD mixed it up by randomly giving hints or having the secret passages tie you up and make you lose a turn.

I never balked at the idea of changes to Clue, but when I read this morning that Hasbro would be “updating” the game in the fall, I was apprehensive before I clicked the link to read the news article.

Gone are the polite and mysterious titles of the characters, no more Professor, no more Miss, no more Colonel. The characters all have first names now. I don't understand why this is important. If they wanted to update the names a bit to be modern, how about some gender equality? Colonel Mustard, meet Corporal Peacock. Nurse Plum, meet Doctor Scarlet. Queen Green, meet Pre-op Transexual White.

The characters all have backgrounds now, Kasandra Scarlet is a celebrity who is hounded by the tabloids. I guess we can rule her out as the potential murderer if the paparazzi are on her ass. If Lindsay Lohan or one of the Olsen Twins decided the club someone to death, TMZ.com would have the video posted before the victim knew what was happening.

I'm going to guess that it's Jack Mustard, the former football player, with the knife, in Brentwood.


In the press release, it only says that Jacob Green is an African-American. Can we really accuse this game of not being racially diverse enough? Cite my lack of imagination if you desire, but in more than two decades I never even considered the race of the little differently colored game pieces, despite the fact that one of them is NAMED White. That, and if I'm going to be accusing people of capital offenses, I'd like to think that I'll not be hurtling my random accusations toward ethnic minorities.

Professor Plum is now a billionaire video game designer. Is this Hasbro's subtle revenge for the decline of the board game industry at the hands of the dastardly video game? Name one famous billionaire video game designer. I didn't think so.
Of course the characters aren't the only thing Hasbro has decided to change. There will be new rooms, such as a spa, a guest house and a home theater. They might as well add a grotto, since in my head this whole thing is already taking place at the Playboy mansion. Although in that case we would need exactly 2 suspect cards “dirty old man” and “platinum bottle blond with suspect intelligence.”

I wonder which rooms they decided to replace. I'm betting on the Conservatory. Who has a Conservatory anymore? Who had a Conservatory EVER? Every house I see on MTV Cribs has a pool table, so maybe the Billiard Room made the cut. I'm thinking that either the Study or the Library has been eliminated.

(A bit of further investigation has revealed that both the Study AND the Library are gone. Why not a dumbed-down house for a dumbed-down society? Our buddy Billiard Room didn't survive either. But fear not, the Observatory is still there!)


The weapons, too, have been updated. I can't argue with that. You don't read a lot about people being beaten to death with lead pipes or wrenches these days. They've added an ax. I approve of the potential imagined gore that can be carried out on these stupid stereotypical cookie-cutter characters. Also added to the lineup of weapons: dumbells, a baseball bat, a trophy and poison.

In what is potentially the only positive thing to come out of this Clue-redux is the fact that they are adding a new element of game play with a second deck of cards. Although full details haven't been made available yet, it is said that this deck changes the time frame of the game, eliminating characters if the murder isn't solved fast enough and the murderer strikes again.

This updated version will fully replace the Clue that has been on the shelves for decades. The change will take place this fall.

Coincidentally, I will be in Chicago the second and third week of November. This may be your small window of opportunity to score a victory over Jim and me, while we frantically try to develop new unbeatable strategies.

Bring beer.